HS2 is a ‘killer whale’ for next prime minister, says Kit Malthouse

HS2 is a 'killer whale' for next prime minister, says Kit Malthouse

Cabinet Office minister says rail project 'waiting to breach waves and rip arm off' Liz Truss or Rishi Sunak

HS2 workers build a tunnel at Chipping Warden near Banbury

The Cabinet Office minister Kit Malthouse has described the HS2 rail project as a "killer whale" that could "rip the arm" off the next prime minister.

In an intervention that will alarm supporters of the multibillion-pound rail upgrade, Malthouse said it could "derail" the premiership of Rishi Sunak or Liz Truss.

Rishi Sunak says he is underdog in PM race as 'forces that be' want Truss Read more

In an interview with the Sunday Telegraph, he said: "These are the big projects that sit out there below the surface, waiting to breach above the waves and rip your arm off. Big projects with big money involved, that often take quite a lot of sophisticated leadership and management.

"And we need to just make sure that we've got the risk assessed properly on that for a new prime minister."

The plan for HS2 was unveiled 10 years ago and intended as a once in a multi-generation upgrade to England's ailing rail network, helping to rebalance the economy by speeding up journey times between London, the Midlands, Manchester and Leeds.

However, the project has been beset by technical and management problems that have left it years behind schedule, billions of pounds over budget, and reduced in scale.

The London and Birmingham leg was due to open at the end of 2026 but this is now expected between 2029 and 2033. The second phase, between the Midlands and north-west England, was due to open in 2032-33 but has been pushed back to 2035-2040.

The planned eastern leg - which would have slashed journey times between the east Midlands, Leeds and Bradford - was scrapped in November, prompting outrage from northern leaders.

The estimated cost of HS2 is expected to near GBP100bn compared with an original budget of GBP55.7bn in 2015.

Unfinished business: policies that could fail under UK's 'lame-duck' government Read more

Malthouse was promoted to chancellor of the duchy of Lancaster, the most senior ministerial role in the cabinet, in Boris Johnson's forced reshuffle before his resignation on 7 July.

Speaking of the challenges facing government, he said the Cabinet Office was "a pretty good engine" but one that was "recovering from Covid".

He said HS2 was a "big project and it's definitely on the list" of "killer whales".

"HS2 is obviously making significant progress," he said. "What I want is when a new prime minister comes in, that he or she is able to say to me: Kit, what should I be worried about?

That's the exercise that we're going through over the next four to six weeks."

A HS2 Ltd spokesperson said: "With over 350 construction sites active between London and Crewe, three giant tunnelling machines currently underground, and works started on our viaducts and stations, HS2 is on budget and making fantastic progress.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter - every weekday morning at 7am BST [embedded content]

"Furthermore, the project is providing work for over 26,000 people, with tens of thousands more jobs supported through our wider supply chain, and more than 2,500 companies awarded HS2 contracts to date.

"HS2 is zero-carbon public transport that will play a vital part in the government's ambitions to level up the Midlands and north."

Topics Reuse this content